This Year’s Dallas Keuchel Will Be T.J. House

When preparing for a new season, fantasy baseball enthusiasts are always wanting to know who is going to be the next big breakout player.  Drafting or picking up a player on waivers for his breakout season gives fantasy owners a feeling of superiority, a feeling of omniscience in some sense.  Whether that feeling is justified or not is another question.  But even if your team comes in last place, you can take ownership that you “knew” Jose Bautista would bust out for 54 HR, or that your hunch that R.A. Dickey would knuckle his way into a Cy Young Award panned out.  So at The Backwards K, there is a series of posts titled “This Year’s…” where I will tell you who I think this year’s version of a 2014 breakout player will be, providing some background and analysis.

Embed from Getty Images

Before the 2014 season, you have to go to back to 2010 to find a Houston Astros starting pitcher that was worth owning in fantasy leagues.  That pitcher was Brett Myers who went 14-8 with a 3.14 ERA, 1.24 WHIP, and 180 K in 223.2 IP.  But even then, did you really want to own a player who uses his wife as a punching bag and who once also ignorantly and insensitively called a reporter the “R-word.”   (Spread the word to end the word HERE!)  Something strange happened in 2014 though, as not only one Astros starting pitcher was beginning to produce positive results, but two of them were!  Those pitchers were Dallas Keuchel and Colin McHugh.  The fantasy world seemed affected by the recency bias toward the Astros as an awful team over the past few seasons, and more specifically the Astros pitchers, so many fantasy owners shied away from touching them when they were producing early on, in fear of them turning back into big ol’ pumpkins.  But there of course were the fantasy owners who were bold enough, and perhaps knowledgeable enough, to pick up Keuchel and/or McHugh off waivers.  For now, let’s focus on the southpaw Keuchel and see how he was able to put together a breakout 2014 season.

Keuchel, a 7th round pick out of the University of Arkansas by the Astros in 2009, did not put up any numbers that “wowed” anyone at the collegiate level, as his personal best season at Arkansas consisted of a 3.92 ERA, 1.35 WHIP, and 5.75 K/9.  Similarly, in his Minor League career, he compiled a 3.74 ERA, 1.23 WHIP, and 5.90 K/9.  And then in his 1 and ½ seasons in the Majors prior to 2014, he was a pitcher that looked absolutely lost, as he was literally one of the worst pitchers in the league during that timeframe.   Out of pitchers with a minimum of 200 IP from 2012-13, Keuchel had the third highest ERA at 5.20 and the highest WHIP at 1.54.  Part of the ugly stat line could be attributed to some poor luck as his xFIP (expected fielding independent pitching mark) during that time was 4.17, which was over a full run lower than his actual ERA, suggesting his defense was doing him no favors.  However, there was still no denying that Keuchel had a lot of work to do to become anything more than an eventual mop-up man in the Majors.

A part of Keuchel’s game that was a positive aspect in his time in the Minors but was not prevalent at all during his first 1 and ½ years in the Majors was his great control.  In the Minors his walk rate was well below average at 1.90 BB/9, but in 2012 with the Astros it ballooned to 4.11 BB/9.  Perhaps that 2012 mark can be attributed to the rookie jitters though, as Keuchel was able to trim that to 3.05 BB/9 in his sophomore season in 2013.  Even so, that was still a far cry from his Mark Buehrle-esque type of control that he had in the Minors.  But in 2014 things started clicking for Keuchel, and he was getting ahead in the count much more often, as his first pitch strike % increased from 62.9% in 2013 to 65.4% in 2014.  Working ahead in the count is obviously a lot more comfortable for pitchers, and it should lead to fewer walks issued.  In Keuchel’s case, it led to a lot fewer walks as his 2014 walk rate was very pretty at 2.16 BB/9.  Another factor in Keuchel’s breakout was the fact that he was pounding the bottom of the zone, as evidenced in this great article written by Scott Strandberg at Fangraphs.  Keuchel always was a groundball pitcher, but by pounding the bottom of the zone even harder, he took his groundball inducing ways to a whole new level.  At 63.5%, Keuchel easily led the Majors in groundball rate.  Groundballs often turn into easy outs, and if the ball is being hit on the ground a lot that means the ball is not leaving the park for 3-run dingers.  So as you can see, Keuchel’s formula to success in his age 26 season was improved control and inducing a ton of groundballs, which led him to a season of 12 W-9 L, 2.93 ERA, 1.18 WHIP, 6.57 K/9, and 2.16 BB/9 in 200 IP.

Embed from Getty Images

As soon as the 2014 season ended, I had T.J. House of the Indians already pegged to be this year’s Dallas Keuchel, but then the Indians went and made what I thought to be a weird signing by agreeing to a one-year/$4 million deal with veteran Gavin Floyd with the intention of handing him a spot in the starting rotation.  Guaranteeing a spot in the rotation to a guy who made just 5 starts in 2013 before undergoing Tommy John surgery and who made just 9 starts in 2014 before undergoing surgery to repair a fracture in his throwing elbow?  That does not sound very smart to me, especially considering that the Indians had cheaper in-house options (no pun intended) such as House, Danny Salazar, Trevor Bauer, Zach McAllister, and Josh Tomlin.  If Floyd is healthy, two out of those five pitchers should still crack the rotation, but it looks like House would be on the outside looking in.  However, on March 6, Floyd had his live batting practice session cut short due to elbow soreness.  If this is a lingering thing for Floyd or if it snowballs into something worse, that bodes well for House to get a chance.  So for that reason, I am going to go with my initial instinct and nominate House to be this year’s version of Keuchel.  Now let’s see why.

The left-handed throwing House is a home grown product of the Indians as he was selected in the 16th round of the 2008 draft by the team.  Coming up through the farm system of the Indians, like Keuchel in the farm system of the Astros, House was mostly unimpressive.  In his career in the Minors, House has posted a 3.95 ERA, 1.38 WHIP, 7.00 K/9, and 3.47 BB/9, and judging by the numbers he failed to make any significant improvements as he ascended Minor League levels.  Despite the rather mediocre stats, House was promoted to the Majors last May and made one relief appearance before finishing out the season in the starting rotation as he made 18 starts.  Overall, House finished his rookie year going 5-3 with a 3.35 ERA, 1.32 WHIP, 7.06 K/9, and 1.94 BB/9 in 102 IP.

House’s final 2014 line looks pretty nifty already, but there are even more reasons to appreciate it and have greater hopes for him in 2015.  Upon reaching the Majors, House struggled early on posting a 4.50 ERA and 1.56 WHIP, 5.76 K/9, and 2.52 BB/9 in 50 IP over 1 relief appearance and 9 starts.  But over the final two months of the season, he brought the house down so to speak and just got better and better to suggest he was figuring this whole pitching thing out.  Over his final 9 starts, he had a 2.25 ERA, 1.14 WHIP, 8.31 K/9, and 1.38 BB/9 in 52 IP.  Furthermore, House’s BABIP was .332, which is fairly high and ranked as the 9th highest BABIP out of pitchers with at least 100 IP.  This indicates that House may have been unlucky and possibly should have had even better than a 3.35 ERA and 1.32 WHIP.

Another thing to like about House and his 2015 outlook, and to give further comparison to Keuchel, is the fact that he was insanely good at inducing groundballs last year.  Out of pitchers with a minimum of 100 IP, House’s 60.9% groundball rate ranked second to guess who?  Well, unless you have some major short term memory issues you shouldn’t have to guess considering I already started earlier that Keuchel led the league with a 63.5% groundball rate.

So as you can see, these two pitchers are very similar and this is why I like House to be this year’s Keuchel.  However, there are two concerns I have that House will not have this type of breakout.  One concern is the aforementioned playing time issue.  Will House accumulate enough starts?  The second concern is the fact that in the Minors, House never showed the type of control that he did last year with the Indians.  Did he actually turn a corner in that department or will he begin to issue many more free passes?  Regardless, seeing House’s name appear on this rankings list of pitch arsenal scores compiled by Eno Sarris of FanGraphs makes me feel a bit more comfortable liking the 25-year old House.  We are just going to want to monitor what happens in Spring Training in the starting rotation battle for the Indians.

***UPDATE (3/10/15):  Gavin Floyd has been diagnosed with with a re-injury of the stress fracture in his right elbow.  This should mean that House should be penciled in to a spot in the Indians rotation.  Projection for House is updated below.

2015 Dallas Keuchel stats:  12 W-9 L, 2.93 ERA, 1.18 WHIP, 147 K, 51 BB in 200 IP

2015 T.J. House projection:  10 W-6 L 3.12 ERA, 1.25 WHIP, 115 K, 39 BB in 150 IP   12 W-9 L, 3.18 ERA, 1.26 WHIP, 139 K, 48 BB in 181 IP

ʞonfidence Rating:  3ʞ out of 10ʞ

Other candidates to be “This Year’s Dallas Keuchel”:  Kyle Gibson, Vance Worley


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s